A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

Crossword books: a newspaper experiment becomes a publishing business

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Match each person with the correct contribution. The people are Arthur Wynne, Margaret Farrar. The objects are 1913 newspaper grid, 1924 book editing. Each slot contains one person and one object; use each person and contribution exactly once. Which pairing is correct?

Read the full story

Crossword books: a newspaper experiment becomes a publishing business

Crossword books grew out of a newspaper pastime that Arthur Wynne introduced in New York in 1913. The first grid was a diamond, with intersecting horizontal and vertical words and no black squares. In 1924, a collection edited by Margaret Petherbridge, later Margaret Farrar, helped launch the publishing partnership of Richard Simon and Max Schuster. Between those events, a recurring feature became material for a different kind of publication: a book sold with a pencil. [1, 2, 3]

Wynne came from Liverpool and emigrated to the United States. He remembered a word game from childhood called Magic Square, in which words were arranged to cross. While working for the New York World, he had space to fill in its Fun section. His new construction appeared on December 21, 1913. Numbered squares provided starting points for the entries, and accompanying clues supplied the words to be fitted into the design. [1, 3]

The crossings joined two directions of reading. A horizontal word supplied letters to vertical words, while the vertical entries constrained the horizontal ones. Wynne’s diamond had no dark squares separating groups of white cells. This made its shape visibly different from the familiar blocked grids that later became standard in American crossword publishing. The combination of a diagram, numbers and short clues provided a compact package that could occupy a newspaper feature slot. [1, 3]

Wynne continued creating and editing crosswords for the World for eight years. He suggested that his employers seek copyright protection for the new feature, but the newspaper did not take up that suggestion. His successor, Petherbridge, developed the editorial practice further. She favored words in ordinary English use and limited the amount of black space in the grid. The continuity of the feature therefore involved both new constructions and decisions about vocabulary and layout. [3]

Across the Atlantic, Pearson’s Magazine carried a crossword in February 1922. In the United States, Simon’s aunt had become an enthusiastic solver of the World’s puzzles and asked whether a collection was available in book form. Simon discovered that there was no such volume. He and Schuster decided to publish one. Simon had previously sold pianos, and the two men had met during that part of his working life. [1]

Newspaper columnist Franklin P. Adams helped connect the prospective publishers with Petherbridge. She brought in two colleagues, Prosper Buranelli and F. Gregory Hartswick, to work on the collection. The three editors selected 50 previously unpublished puzzles that had been submitted to the World. The book consequently drew on the newspaper’s pool of constructions without simply binding up a run of puzzles already printed for its subscribers. [2]

The Cross Word Puzzle Book appeared on April 10, 1924. At first, Simon and Schuster used the imprint Plaza Publishing Company, taking the name from their telephone exchange. They were uncertain about associating their own names with a project that might fail. Adams introduced the partnership to his newspaper audience in his Conning Tower column, giving the young publishers publicity at the moment of release. [2]

The original printing of 3,600 copies sold out quickly. Further printings brought total sales to 400,000. A pencil accompanied the book, making the volume and the means of filling it in part of the same retail object. Petherbridge continued editing the series for 60 years, long after she became known by the surname Farrar. [1, 3]

Crossword books also circulated in Britain. The National Library of Scotland holds a 1924 Hodder and Stoughton edition received through legal deposit. Its puzzles and clues match the first half of the American collection. One grid measures eleven cells by eleven, with 24 black squares among its 121 cells. The volume includes introductory guidance but no separate solution section at the back. A pristine library copy preserves a form intended for marks made by its owner. [1]

The vocabulary of early crossword books could leave several candidates for one short entry. In the preserved 1924 grid, the three-letter clue digit could suggest toe, one, two, six or ten. Its crossing entries constrained which candidate could fit. A five-letter clue for a neckerchief could likewise suggest scarf before the intersecting words supplied further restrictions. The densely connected eleven-by-eleven layout made these interactions part of the construction: one plausible word affected several other entries through shared cells. [1]

The 1924 venture linked three different jobs: construction, editing and publication. Wynne established the recurring newspaper feature. Petherbridge and her co-editors assembled unused constructions into a collection, applying editorial judgment to language and grid design. Simon and Schuster packaged that collection for sale outside the newspaper. Crossword books developed from those separate contributions, while Farrar’s long association with the series carried its editorial work across decades. [2, 3]

[1] Graeme Hawley, National Library of Scotland: From clues to collections. https://www.nls.uk/collections/stories/life-in-the-library/from-clues-to-collections-a-puzzle-in-the-library/

[2] Ben Zimmer, Crossword Craze: April 10, 1924, the craze begins. https://crosswordcraze.today/april-10-1924-the-craze-begins/

[3] Judith Nierman, U.S. Copyright Office: Crossword puzzles, Copyright Lore, April 2015. https://www.copyright.gov/history/lore/pdfs/201504%20CLore_April2015.pdf

Show the answer

The Answer

Arthur Wynne: 1913 newspaper grid; Margaret Farrar: 1924 book editing.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.