A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

Magic squares: Dürer’s engraving and Franklin’s bent diagonals

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Match each person with the correct contribution. The people are Albrecht Dürer, Benjamin Franklin. The objects are 1514 engraving, eight-by-eight bent-diagonal square. Each slot contains one person and one object; use each person and contribution exactly once. Which pairing is correct?

Read the full story

Magic squares: Dürer’s engraving and Franklin’s bent diagonals

Magic squares connect arithmetic with two very different objects: Albrecht Dürer’s 1514 engraving Melencolia I and Benjamin Franklin’s eight-by-eight number arrangement. Dürer placed a four-by-four square on a wall, with rows, columns and the two main diagonals totaling 34. Franklin’s larger construction has rows and columns totaling 260, together with an elaborate system of bent diagonals. Their patterns occupy different settings, one in a crowded print and the other in correspondence about mathematical recreations. [1, 2, 3]

In Melencolia I, a winged figure sits with her head supported by one hand and a pair of dividers in the other. Geometrical instruments and a polyhedron surround her. A small childlike figure writes while sitting on a millstone. An hourglass and bell hang nearby, and a comet crosses the sky. The date 1514 appears within the number square itself, as well as elsewhere in the composition. The square brings a numerical order into this densely furnished scene. [1, 2]

Dürer made these objects with engraved lines on a copper plate, producing tones between black ink and white paper through different arrangements of marks. Fur, cloth and stone have distinct textures. Impressions from the same plate can also differ: later printing can make lines less sharp, and a scratch on the plate can appear in subsequent impressions. The physical history of the print therefore accompanies its geometric imagery. [1]

Other artists changed that imagery. Hans Sebald Beham’s smaller Melencolia of 1539 omits the number square and polyhedron. Johannes Wierix made a close copy of Dürer’s composition in 1602. Much later, Kiki Smith’s 1999 version exchanged the dividers for a printmaking tool. The instruments and numbers belonged to a composition that could be copied closely or altered selectively. [1]

Franklin’s route into magic squares began with a conversation at James Logan’s country house. Logan showed him a French folio containing the squares of Bernard Frénicle de Bessy and discussed the arithmetic work required to make them. Franklin remembered an eight-by-eight square among his papers and brought it on another visit. In a letter to Peter Collinson, he described the arrangement and the numerical patterns Logan had inspected. [3]

The basic totals were only the beginning. Each full row and column of Franklin’s smaller square adds to 260, and each half-row and half-column adds to 130. The four numbers at the outer corners, together with the four at the center, also total 260. Instead of restricting attention to straight lines across the square, Franklin traced eight-number paths that bend and still reach the same sum. [3]

These bent paths run in four orientations: from top to bottom, from right to left, from bottom to top and from left to right. Some wrap into separate portions at the boundary rather than remaining a single continuous shape within the frame. Each such diagonal uses eight cells. There is also a smaller-scale pattern: every two-by-two subsquare has a total of 130. Large paths and small blocks therefore obey related numerical constraints within the same arrangement. [4]

Logan then showed Franklin another book, by Michael Stifel, containing a sixteen-by-sixteen square. Its rows, columns and principal diagonals added to 2,056. Franklin went home and made a square of that size that evening, sending it to Logan the next morning. His letter describes both the familiar full-length totals and further patterns he had built into the larger construction. The shift in size supplied much more than a larger collection of entries. [3]

In that larger square, a four-by-four block contains sixteen entries totaling 2,056. The block can move across the arrangement and retain that sum. Franklin also described half-row and half-column totals of 1,028 and full bent-row totals of 2,056. Along with these, he identified groups involving corners and central cells. The letter proceeds through these configurations as distinct properties, rather than treating the ordinary row total as the whole achievement. [3]

Magic squares also prompted a debate about the value of recreation. At Logan’s house, Franklin initially described the constructions as difficult activities without useful applications. Logan compared them with arithmetic and mathematical challenges publicly posed in England. Franklin responded that practice could encourage readiness and exactness in mathematical investigation. Logan applied that same defense to the squares. Their conversation led Franklin to bring an older eight-by-eight arrangement from his papers on his next visit. [3]

The two sizes give Franklin’s constructions a hierarchy of sums: halves relate to full rows, and compact blocks relate to longer paths. Dürer’s four-by-four arrangement instead places a total of 34 into the architecture of an engraving, with the year embedded in its bottom row. Magic squares could thus function as pictured mathematical objects, as arrangements passed between correspondents, and as systems whose patterns extend beyond their horizontal and vertical lines. [2, 3, 4]

[1] Nadine Orenstein, Metropolitan Museum of Art: Dürer’s Melencolia I. https://www.metmuseum.org/perspectives/melencolia-i

[2] National Galleries of Scotland: Melencolia I, collection record. https://www.nationalgalleries.org/art-and-artists/34333/melencolia-i

[3] Benjamin Franklin to Peter Collinson: The Arithmetical Curiosity, historical letter. https://historycarper.com/1752/01/01/the-arithmetical-curiosity/

[4] William H. Richardson, Wichita State University: Ben Franklin’s Little Magic Square. https://www.math.wichita.edu/~richardson/littleben.html

Show the answer

The Answer

Albrecht Dürer: 1514 engraving; Benjamin Franklin: eight-by-eight bent-diagonal square.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.