Stomachion puzzle: fourteen pieces and hundreds of squares
The Stomachion puzzle consists of 14 geometric pieces that fit together into a square. An ancient text associated with Archimedes examines the dissection, while modern searches have counted its possible square arrangements. In 2003, Bill Cutler’s computer enumeration found 536 arrangements after treating rotations, reflections and exchanges of identical pieces as equivalent. A related count of 17,152 keeps distinctions that the smaller total removes. The choice of what counts as different is central to these numbers. [1, 2, 3]
The ancient material survives through two different textual routes. An Arabic version, found in a Berlin manuscript, was published in 1899. A Greek version came to light in the Archimedes Palimpsest in 1906. Of the Stomachion treatise, the Greek manuscript preserves an introduction and the opening of its first proposition. These remnants differ from a complete manual listing finished arrangements: they are portions of a much older mathematical investigation. [1]
The physical position of the Greek text made it unusually difficult to recover. Stomachion was the last treatise in the mathematical manuscript, and its surviving leaf had suffered substantial damage. The Archimedes project’s 2004 interpretation connected the text with counting different arrangements of the pieces. That is a modern interpretation of fragmentary ancient material; the detailed total of 536 belongs to the modern enumeration, rather than to a surviving numerical result written by Archimedes. [1]
Recovering the Stomachion puzzle manuscript required conservation before detailed imaging could proceed. At the Walters Art Museum, conservator Abigail Quandt began taking apart its binding in February 2000 and finished that stage in November 2004. The underlying mathematical writing ran through the folded gutters. Separating the leaves made those areas accessible, but a modern adhesive on part of the spine was tougher than the parchment and made separation particularly difficult. [4]
The parchment had been reused for a prayer book. Wax from that later use obscured parts of the earlier writing. Quandt documented the condition of individual leaves, removed obstructing material and unfolded damaged areas for imaging. Fragile sections received supports of Japanese paper. After imaging, the leaves were stabilized further and placed in double-sided frames. The geometric text therefore depended on conservation of a layered physical artifact, as well as on mathematical interpretation. [4]
A separate modern route led through manufactured puzzle pieces. Early in 2003, Joe Marasco commissioned a version of the dissection from puzzle maker Kate Jones. The 14 pieces divide a twelve-by-twelve square, and each piece has an integer area in those units. A Lucite version appeared at that year’s International Puzzle Party. Ed Pegg Jr. subsequently directed Jones toward Cutler, who adapted a computer program to enumerate the square constructions. [3]
Cutler completed that calculation on October 31, 2003, after five days of work on the program. His 536 treats a turned or mirrored whole square as the same arrangement, and it also ignores exchanges between congruent pieces. Work involving Persi Diaconis, Susan Holmes, Fan Chung and Ron Graham produced the larger count of 17,152. The two totals use different conventions about symmetry and piece identity. [1, 3]
There is another reduction inside the geometry. Three pairs of pieces must remain together in any square tiling. Joining those pairs produces an eleven-piece version called STOMACH, made by George Miller. When exchanges of congruent pieces are treated as equivalent, it has 2,144 square tilings. Removing rotations and reflections leaves 268. This eleven-piece version and the original fourteen-piece dissection have different counting conventions, so their totals describe different mathematical objects. [2]
Chung and Graham also connected the 268 reduced tilings by moves. Each arrangement becomes a vertex in a graph. An edge joins two arrangements when a symmetric portion can be turned or flipped to transform one into the other. Their graph has 937 edges. Almost all the arrangements sit in one connected component containing 266 vertices and 936 edges; the remaining two form a separate component with a single edge. [2]
The Stomachion puzzle manuscript also underwent material analysis. The Canadian Conservation Institute examined a pinhead-sized sample and advised on the parchment’s condition. Its collagen remained reasonably sound except in mold-affected areas, where it was disintegrating. Conservation maps recorded wax, glue and modern residues on individual leaves. Even the material removed during treatment was logged and stored. Local humidification then relaxed the animal-skin leaves sufficiently for imaging, preserving the distinction between preparation of the object and digital recovery of its writing. [4]
That larger component has a cycle visiting all 266 of its arrangements exactly once before returning to the start. Its greatest shortest-path distance is eleven moves under the specified transformations. Thus the Stomachion puzzle supports more than a count of finished squares: it also has a structure describing travel between them. Its ancient dissection, modern physical sets and computer-generated network reveal different properties of the same family of pieces. [2, 3]
[1] Reviel Netz, Archimedes Palimpsest Project: Combinatorics. https://archimedespalimpsest.org/about/scholarship/combinatorics.php
[2] Fan Chung and Ron Graham, University of California San Diego: A tour of STOMACH. https://fanchung.ucsd.edu/stomach/tour/stomach.html
[3] Kate Jones, Kadon Enterprises: The Archimedes Square. https://gamepuzzles.com/tlog/tlog24.htm
[4] Archimedes Palimpsest Project: Conservation by Abigail Quandt. https://archimedespalimpsest.org/about/conservation.php
- Reviel Netz, Archimedes Palimpsest Project: Combinatorics — archimedespalimpsest.org