A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

Word ladder: lid to set?

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Change one letter at a time to turn lid into set in 3 steps.

Read the full story

From lid to set: one letter at a time

Lid -> lit -> sit -> set is a three-step connection made one letter at a time. The final d becomes t, the initial l becomes s, and the central i becomes e. Lit creates the t that both later rungs require. Sit then introduces the s while leaving the vowel available for the closing change. The ending has to change before that first consonant in this particular sequence; changing lid's opening letter directly would give sid, which is not the selected common-word bridge. Lid and set differ in all three positions, so three substitutions are enough and no shorter route could correct every difference.

Changing one letter first exchanges a covering for a form of the verb light. Lid is a surviving Old English word, recorded before 1000 in Dictionary.com. It passed through Middle English from Old English hlid, with relatives including Dutch and German lid and an Old Norse word for a gate.[1] Its central idea of covering remains visible in a container's top, but the same noun can refer to an eyelid, a hat, or a restraint on prices or information. These extensions move from a physical cover to something that limits activity.[1] Wiktionary's 1960 example from P. G. Wodehouse's Jeeves in the Offing uses lid for a deerstalker hat, humorously judged by its ability to frighten crows.[2] A familiar household object has supplied names for coverings both bodily and wearable.

Lit was already established by the 18th century: Wiktionary records disapproval of this past form in the 18th and 19th centuries, when lighted was preferred.[4] Its ancestry is much older. Dictionary.com records the lighting verb before 900, with Old English līhtan and Middle English lighten.[3] Wiktionary traces the past form through Old English līhtte and Middle English lighte, explaining that the modern shortening followed the pattern of bit.[4] The illuminated meaning later gained slang companions: intoxicated, exciting, and excellent. In a letter dated 16 February 1932, Hart Crane reported that he had become very lit the previous night, using the intoxication sense.[4][9] The same short form now does work as both an ordinary verb form and an adjective of enthusiasm.

The move from lit to sit changes one letter; sit reaches back before 900, through Middle English sitten to Old English sittan. Dictionary.com compares Dutch zitten, German sitzen, and Old Norse sitja, showing a family of related verbs rather than a recent borrowing.[5] Resting on the body became a broader language of remaining, occupying a position, or fitting: a court can sit in session, a committee member can sit on a body, and a garment can sit well.[5][6] Wiktionary includes a 1651 example from Jeremy Taylor's The Rule and Exercises of Holy Living in which calamity sits heavily upon people.[6] No physical chair is involved in that use. The seated body's settled weight has become a way of expressing an emotional burden.

Set is historically connected with sit, as well as being close in spelling. Dictionary.com dates it before 900 and traces Middle English setten to Old English settan, from a Germanic verb meaning to cause to sit.[7] Placing something developed into arranging, establishing, or putting it into a condition: the verb can set an alarm, a table, or someone thinking.[7][8] Wiktionary supplies Samuel Taylor Coleridge's 1827 sentence about an incident that sets someone thinking, an example of causing a state rather than physically positioning an object.[8][10] The noun for a group has an additional history through Old French and Latin secta, later influenced by the English verb.[7] A single modern spelling consequently joins inherited verbal ancestry with another strand of noun formation.

Changing one letter links lid's inherited cover, lit's reshaped past tense, and sit and set's history of sitting and causing something to sit.[1][4][5][7]

[1] Dictionary.com: Lid Definition & Meaning. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/lid

[2] Wiktionary: lid. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/lid

[3] Dictionary.com: Light Definition & Meaning. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/light

[4] Wiktionary: lit. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/lit

[5] Dictionary.com: Sit Definition & Meaning. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/sit

[6] Wiktionary: sit. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/sit

[7] Dictionary.com: Set Definition & Meaning. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/set

[8] Wiktionary: set. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/set

[9] Hart Crane, edited by Brom Weber: The Letters of Hart Crane 1916-1932, letter 391. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/76626/76626-h/76626-h.htm

[10] Samuel Taylor Coleridge: Specimens of the Table Talk. https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/8489/pg8489-images.html

Show the answer

The Answer

lid -> lit -> sit -> set. Each step changes exactly one letter: lid to lit changes d to t at position 3; lit to sit changes l to s at position 1; sit to set changes i to e at position 2.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.