A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

A 4-step letter puzzle

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Change one letter per step to turn book into tail in 4 steps.

Read the full story

From book to tail: one letter at a time

Book -> took -> tool -> toil -> tail changes one letter at a time in positions one, four, three, and two. B gives way to t, k to l, the second o to i, and the first o to a. Took preserves the doubled vowel while giving the chain the initial t needed for tail. Tool then supplies the final l before either vowel changes. That ending is important: changing the third letter of took directly to i would produce toik. Toil carries both outside letters of tail and needs only the second-position vowel changed. The endpoints differ in four places, so four moves achieve the minimum.

Book is documented before 900, from Old English bōc through Middle English; its Germanic relatives include Dutch boek and German Buch.[1] The noun covers both a bound object and the work it contains, allowing a book to remain a book when issued electronically. Other meanings include a division within a long work and business accounts. In The Tempest, written in 1610 to 1611 and printed in 1623, the speaker recalls books valued above his dukedom. The history accommodates both tangible volumes and a work considered apart from its binding.[2]

The speaker in The Tempest is Prospero, telling Miranda how they were sent away from Milan. He credits Gonzalo with supplying food, water, clothes, and volumes from his library. The books belong among the material provisions carried with them, yet Prospero values them above his former dukedom. The scene brings their physical and intellectual importance together: they are portable volumes whose contents matter enough to be compared with political power and property. Their value exceeds the binding while still depending on actual objects that could be taken along. [12]

Took is a past form within a borrowed verb family. Dictionary.com records take before 1100, from late Old English tacan, derived from Old Norse taka, meaning to take or grasp.[3] Middle English taken already had the past form tok, documented in Wiktionary's conjugation.[4] The meaning extends beyond gripping an object to bringing someone along. A 1963 example from Margery Allingham's The China Governess describes Tim taking Barry Leach with him while holding his arm. Wiktionary also records took as a participle now labeled colloquial or dialectal, illustrating that grammatical use with Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, written around 1601 to 1602 and printed in 1623.[5]

Tool continues Old English tōl through Middle English and is recorded before 900.[6] Wiktionary connects it with Old English tāwian, to make or prepare, while treating a possible Norse borrowing cautiously. The central meaning is a physical implement that helps accomplish work. Modern extensions include a means of achieving something and a piece of software used for technical operations. Brian Hayes's American Scientist article of 2012-03 calls diagrams, maps, photographs, and other pictorial devices tools for presenting evidence and explaining theories. That dated example makes a tool an aid to thought and communication, extending the workshop idea without requiring a handheld implement.[7]

The distinction between an implement and a means is also visible in tool. A screwdriver works physically on an object, whereas a diagram can help a reader understand a relationship. The dictionary records physical devices, means of performing an operation, and computing software separately. Calling each a tool identifies assistance toward a task, while the more specific entry explains how that assistance is supplied. [7]

Toil's labor sense follows a history of conflict. Dictionary.com dates the Middle English noun to 1300 to 1350, when toil or toile meant violent conflict or battle, from Anglo-French and Old French terms for contention. It traces that noun ultimately to Latin tudiculare, to stir up or beat, associated with a machine for crushing olives.[8] Modern toil emphasizes strenuous, sustained work. In John Milton's Paradise Lost of 1667, the verb describes laboriously working out an awkward passage, a quotation preserved by Wiktionary. The passage makes the effort of movement central, showing how the vocabulary of struggle can express exhausting progress without naming an actual battle.[9]

Tail is recorded before 900 and comes through Middle English from Old English tægl or tægel. Related words include Old Norse tagl for a horse's tail and Gothic tagl for a single hair.[10] From an animal's appendage, English extends tail to similar trailing shapes, rear portions, and things that follow. Gideon Harvey's Morbus Anglicus of 1672 describes hanging parts of willow trees as tails, a dated botanical comparison quoted by Wiktionary. Modern senses include an aircraft's rear structure, a comet's visible stream, and the distant part of a statistical distribution. Shape and position let an anatomical word travel into mechanics and mathematics.[11]

Book passes took, tool, and toil one letter at a time before tail follows their writing and work with its trailing shape.

[1] Dictionary.com: Book. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/book

[2] Wiktionary: book. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/book

[3] Dictionary.com: Take. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/take

[4] Wiktionary: taken. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/taken

[5] Wiktionary: took. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/took

[6] Dictionary.com: Tool. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/tool

[7] Wiktionary: tool. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tool

[8] Dictionary.com: Toil. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/toil

[9] Wiktionary: toil. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/toil

[10] Dictionary.com: Tail. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/tail

[11] Wiktionary: tail. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tail

[12] William Shakespeare, The Tempest, act 1, scene 2. MIT Shakespeare. https://shakespeare.mit.edu/tempest/tempest.1.2.html

Show the answer

The Answer

book -> took -> tool -> toil -> tail. Each step changes exactly one letter: book to took changes b to t at position 1; took to tool changes k to l at position 4; tool to toil changes o to i at position 3; toil to tail changes o to a at position 2.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.