A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

A 4-step letter puzzle

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Change one letter per step to turn coin into that in 4 steps.

Read the full story

From coin to that: one letter at a time

The four moves are coin -> chin -> thin -> than -> that, with one letter at a time changing in positions two, one, three, and four. O becomes h, c becomes t, i becomes a, and n becomes t. Chin creates the ch spelling before thin introduces th, and the vowel changes only after that new beginning is in place. In this route, the h must precede the first-position t: making that opening change directly in coin would yield toin. Thin and than keep their consonants together while the middle vowel changes. The destination differs from coin at every position, so the four substitutions are also a lower bound.

Coin entered English in 1300 to 1350 through Anglo-French, appearing in Middle English as coyn or coygne. Behind it lies Latin cuneus, a wedge; the French meanings included wedge, corner, and the die used for stamping.[1] The history connects the striking implement with the piece of money it produces. English then carried coin beyond literal currency into figurative payment and things circulating socially. Wiktionary quotes Henry Hammond's Of Fundamentals in a Notion Referring to Practise of 1654, where the loss of a present advantage is repaid in a nobler coin. The repayment is conceptual rather than necessarily a handful of metal.[2]

Chin is recorded before 1000 and descends from Old English cinn through Middle English. Related forms include German Kinn and Latin gena, but the English word follows its inherited Germanic route rather than a Latin borrowing.[3] Its anatomical sense remains the projecting lower part of the face. Modern English transfers that location to the lower front of an aircraft and the area below a phone's screen. A 1990 quotation from Army, preserved by Wiktionary, places an infrared turret in an aircraft's chin. The word supplies an analogy of position and shape, extending facial vocabulary to the construction of a machine.[4]

Thin has a record before 900, with Old English thynne passing into Middle English thynne. Its verb also has an Old English predecessor, thynnian, formed from the adjective.[5] The basic idea of small thickness extends to sparse distribution, weak sound, or inadequate substance. Joseph Addison's Remarks on Several Parts of Italy of 1705 describes Ferrara as large but extremely thin of people, an example quoted in Wiktionary. The city is not physically narrow: thin measures how sparsely its inhabitants occupy the available space. A word for the distance between surfaces has become a description of population density.[6]

Than is documented before 900 and comes from Old English thanne, a variant associated with thonne, the ancestor of then. Its early meanings overlapped comparison, time, and circumstance; related forms include German dann and denn.[7] Modern English chiefly assigns than the work of comparison, though Wiktionary also records an obsolete sense meaning because. A 1665 quotation from A Rational Account of the Grounds of Protestant Religion uses the construction any other way, than because before an appeal to scripture. Than links an alternative with a following clause. The history concerns changes in grammatical relationships alongside the separation of comparative than from temporal then.[8]

The comparative job is visible in a short example: one sheet is thinner than another. Than introduces the second item against which the first is measured. The same construction can compare amounts or degrees without naming two physical objects. Its role differs from the time-ordering work of then, even though the two words share part of their history. Looking at the relationship between the surrounding clauses is therefore more useful than treating either spelling as an interchangeable connector. [7][8]

That continues Old English thæt through Middle English and is recorded before 900. Dictionary.com identifies it originally as the neuter form corresponding to se, meaning the, and notes its Old English roles as pronoun, adjective, adverb, and conjunction.[9] Its development is a branching of grammatical duties: pointing something out, standing for it, or linking a clause. A 2015-11-12 CNN passage quoted by Wiktionary describes expressions and phrases that are recognizable, using that inside a relative clause. The word connects a description with a noun rather than pointing to a distant object. Several grammatical functions coexist within the inherited spelling.[10]

That can do several jobs within similarly short examples. That book uses it to identify an object; I chose that lets it stand alone; the book that I chose uses it to introduce a relative clause. The reference may concern the same book throughout, but the grammatical arrangement changes. Those distinctions fit the dictionary's separate entries for pointing, replacing a noun phrase, and linking a clause. The ladder keeps the spelling fixed while ordinary sentences reveal the different work that spelling can perform. [9][10]

One letter at a time, coin's stamping tool and chin's anatomy lead through thin's spatial measure to than's comparison and that's connecting work.

[1] Dictionary.com: Coin. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/coin

[2] Wiktionary: coin. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/coin

[3] Dictionary.com: Chin. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/chin

[4] Wiktionary: chin. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/chin

[5] Dictionary.com: Thin. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/thin

[6] Wiktionary: thin. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/thin

[7] Dictionary.com: Than. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/than

[8] Wiktionary: than. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/than

[9] Dictionary.com: That. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/that

[10] Wiktionary: that. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/that

Show the answer

The Answer

coin -> chin -> thin -> than -> that. Each step changes exactly one letter: coin to chin changes o to h at position 2; chin to thin changes c to t at position 1; thin to than changes i to a at position 3; than to that changes n to t at position 4.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.