A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

Logic diagrams: Carroll’s counters and Venn’s empty regions

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Match each person with the correct contribution. The people are Lewis Carroll, John Venn. The objects are red and grey counters, overlapping-circle diagrams. Each slot contains one person and one object; use each person and contribution exactly once. Which pairing is correct?

Read the full story

Logic diagrams: Carroll’s counters and Venn’s empty regions

Logic diagrams turn relations among classes into positions on a surface. Lewis Carroll’s Game of Logic uses a square board and colored counters. John Venn’s system uses overlapping regions, with shading to mark an empty class. Both connect verbal statements with spatial arrangements, but the marks have specific meanings: a visible region need not contain an object, and an unmarked region need not be empty. What matters is the information assigned to the drawing. [1, 2, 3]

Carroll’s physical kit contained nine counters, four red and five grey, together with a diagram printed on card. The smaller diagram divides a square into four compartments. Its horizontal division separates an attribute from its negation, while its vertical division makes a second such separation. In his opening example, the attributes are new and nice, within a universe of cakes. Each compartment corresponds to one combination of the two attributes. [1]

The upper-left compartment contains things that are both new and nice. The lower-left represents things that are not new but are nice. The corresponding right-hand compartments carry the not-nice attribute. Red means that a compartment is occupied by at least one object. Grey means that it contains none. Carroll also uses 1 and 0 in printed diagrams to stand for the red and grey counters respectively. [1]

That occupation convention makes some mean one or more. A red counter in the new-and-nice compartment states that at least one member of that combined class exists. A grey counter there states that no member exists in that compartment. A red counter does not specify an exact count of objects, and a grey counter does not say that the class label itself is meaningless. The colors encode presence or absence within a particular part of the chosen universe. [1]

Incomplete information needs a different placement. If something is known to be new, but its niceness is unknown, a red counter sits on the division between the two upper compartments. It records existence somewhere in that half without selecting one side. Grey counters in both upper compartments instead make the entire new class empty. The first placement preserves uncertainty; the second combines two definite exclusions. [1]

Carroll’s larger diagram adds a third attribute, represented by an inner square. The four earlier compartments are split into eight regions. This permits two premises involving three attributes to be represented together. The attribute occurring in the middle term links the premises, and it disappears from the conclusion. Transferring the relevant information back to the smaller diagram displays the relation between the other two attributes. [1]

Venn’s logic diagrams begin from a different kind of completeness: the drawing supplies every possible region before particular information is added. Two overlapping circles allow four combinations of membership in two sets, including the region outside both. The basic drawing alone asserts no specific relation between the sets. Shading the part of A outside B expresses that all A are B; shading the overlap expresses that no A is B. [2]

These conventions differ from simply drawing one circle inside another. A fixed arrangement of class circles can make it difficult to combine pieces of partial information. Venn’s primary diagrams keep the possible regions available and use marks to exclude the appropriate ones. His original system did not supply the later explicit machinery for existential statements. Charles Peirce extended the notation with symbols for existence and with lines joining alternatives. [2]

Venn’s work developed alongside his teaching at Cambridge. He returned there as a lecturer in Moral Science in 1862, studying and teaching logic and probability. He published The Logic of Chance in 1866, Symbolic Logic in 1881 and The Principles of Empirical Logic in 1889. With three sets, his intersecting discs divide the universe into eight nonoverlapping regions; selecting unions of those regions yields 256 Boolean combinations. [3]

Carroll also treats a statement about one specified object as universal when that object forms the whole subject class. The single cake given to someone can constitute all the cakes under consideration in that class. Calling the statement universal then concerns its coverage of the selected subject, rather than a requirement that the subject contain many objects. These logic diagrams distinguish the size of a class from the scope of the assertion made about it, while a particular proposition speaks about some part of its subject. [1]

One historical distinction concerns existence. Carroll represents all new cakes are nice with both a red counter on the new-and-nice side and a grey counter on the new-and-not-nice side. His convention includes the existence of new cakes. Venn’s shading for all A are B excludes the A-outside-B region without making an existential commitment. Logic diagrams therefore depend on their specified rules as well as their outlines: the same verbal-looking universal claim can carry different existence requirements in different systems. [1, 2]

[1] Lewis Carroll, The Game of Logic, primary text and diagrams. https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/4763/pg4763-images.html

[2] Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Diagrams and Diagrammatical Reasoning, section 3.1. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/diagrams/

[3] John O’Connor and Edmund Robertson, University of St Andrews MacTutor: John Venn. https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Venn/

Show the answer

The Answer

Lewis Carroll: red and grey counters; John Venn: overlapping-circle diagrams.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.