A Think Again Media Group publication
Puzzle Stumper

The picture grids behind nonograms: window art and number clues

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Puzzle Stumper

The Question

Match each person with the correct contribution. The people are Non Ishida, James Dalgety. The objects are Window Art Puzzles, Nonogram name. Each slot contains one person and one object; use each person and contribution exactly once. Which pairing is correct?

Read the full story

The picture grids behind nonograms: window art and number clues

The picture grids made from lit and unlit windows inspired nonograms. In 1987, Japanese graphics editor Non Ishida won a Tokyo competition with a skyscraper-light design. The experience suggested a picture reconstructed by filling selected cells of a grid. Tetsuya Nishio independently developed the same kind of pastime at about the same time. Their designs became picture grids in which number clues outside the grid specify groups of filled squares inside it. [1, 2]

Ishida published three examples as Window Art Puzzles in 1988. Nishio used the name Oekaki-Logic, meaning picture logic or drawing logic. In 1989, Ishida showed her work to British puzzle collector James Dalgety. He arranged to commercialize her designs outside Japan. In 1990 he coined Nonogram by combining parts of Ishida’s given name and the word diagram, and persuaded The Sunday Telegraph to introduce the form to its readers. [1, 2]

The newspaper continued with weekly publication after a successful trial. A Japanese book by Ishida and a British Sunday Telegraph collection both appeared in 1993. Mainichi also began regular publication in Japan that year after seeing the Telegraph’s examples. Distribution crossed between Japanese magazines, a British newspaper and books. In 1998, Telegraph readers selected Griddler in a competition for a new name; a first Griddler book followed in 1999. [1]

Another publishing route began when Dave Green encountered these designs during a 1994 visit to Tokyo. With Igor Lerner, he developed a computer algorithm, produced black-and-white examples and introduced the name Pic-a-Pix. Their designs appeared in Japanese monthly magazines in 1995 and in Germany’s PM Magazine in 1998. By 2000, the British magazine Tsunami and two American books supplied further outlets for the form. These were separate developments from Ishida and Dalgety’s original arrangement. [2]

The number clues sit beside the rows and above the columns. In a black-and-white grid, each number gives the length of a consecutive filled block. Numbers occur in the same order as the blocks they describe. Neighboring blocks require at least one empty square between them. The clues identify those lengths and their sequence while leaving the intervening empty spaces to be determined. A completed grid satisfies every row and every column at the same time. [3]

Colored number clues add another property to each block. A block must have the stated length and color, and blocks of the same color still require an empty separator. Blocks of different colors may touch. Thus two adjacent colored groups can remain distinguishable without a blank cell. The information attached to a line governs both its filled cells and its boundaries between groups. Black-and-white and colored grids share the intersecting-row structure while using different separation conditions. [3]

Several line patterns yield immediate restrictions. A line with a zero clue contains no filled cells. A single clue equal to the line’s full length fills it completely. When the block lengths plus their minimum separating spaces exactly occupy the line, every position is fixed. The Puzzle Museum’s example uses blocks of two, three and three cells, with one separator between each: two plus one plus three plus one plus three fills ten cells. [4]

A long block can supply information even when its starting cell is uncertain. If it exceeds half the available line, its furthest-left and furthest-right placements overlap. Every cell in that overlap belongs to the block regardless of the eventual placement. Multiple blocks can likewise be considered together with their minimum separators. An overlap covered by different blocks does not automatically count, because a separating space may occupy that position. [4]

Known empty cells divide a line into shorter available gaps. A gap too short for the required block cannot contain it. Known filled cells can also restrict how far a block extends, excluding cells beyond its maximum reach. Each new mark belongs simultaneously to a row and a column. Information obtained along one direction can therefore restrict the other direction, opening further deductions without guessing the identity of the emerging picture. [4]

By 1995, Pan Books had reached the fourth Sunday Telegraph Book of Nonograms. Ishida wanted to reserve the Nonogram name for her own Japanese designs, and her collaboration with Dalgety ended in 1996. The later reader-selected Griddler name accompanied the Telegraph’s continued publication under its own identity. [1]

These picture grids also prompted an early effort to mechanize that logical process. Dalgety and Bill Stanton wrote a solving program in 1990 designed to use human-style logic. Dalgety’s team used the algorithm to check Telegraph designs and distinguished deductions from guesses based on a recognizable picture. The completed image supplied the visual reward, while intersecting number clues supplied the route to it. The form’s different publishing names retained that connection between a hidden image and constraints operating in two directions. [1, 3]

[1] James Dalgety, The Puzzle Museum: Origins of cross-reference grid and picture-grid puzzles. https://www.puzzlemuseum.com/griddler/gridhist.htm

[2] Conceptis Puzzles, Pic-a-Pix Nonogram history. https://www.conceptispuzzles.com/index.aspx?%75ri=puzzle/pic-a-pix/history

[3] Conceptis Puzzles, Pic-a-Pix Nonogram rules. https://www.conceptispuzzles.com/index.aspx?%75ri=puzzle/pic-a-pix/rules

[4] James Dalgety and The Sunday Telegraph, How to solve griddlers. https://www.puzzlemuseum.com/griddler/gridins.htm

Show the answer

The Answer

Non Ishida: Window Art Puzzles; James Dalgety: Nonogram name.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Puzzle Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.